Mark Gritter (markgritter) wrote,
Mark Gritter

Cargo Noir

Kevin brought "Cargo Noir" to our Easter celebration, and we played it as a 5-player game. It's a reasonably simple auction game built around a "smuggling" theme. Unfortunately that is about the limit of player-to-player interaction--- no trades or conflict. But it goes reasonably fast.

We had one rule question which BoardGameGeek forums say is answered in the printed rules: when you're out of tiles (trade goods) the discards are recycled back into the draw bag. So there is a limit to the benefit of card-counting, but no way to prevent random draws on the last turn. (We had a ton of people sitting in Macau on the last round since they were out of coins.)

The setting is supposed to be 1950-ish. I was sort of bothered by the stereotyped depictions of all of the "player characters"--- Italian, Arabs, Mexicans, Chinese, and Indians. I'm not sure where the line between "lighthearted" and "racist" is here, but I think the "Ti Pot Tong" card was over it. But I was also bothered by what was "OK" to smuggle and what got left out. #1 thing that gets smuggled in the real world? Drugs. But we can't have a game where kids play drug smugglers. So we got ivory, Blood diamonds (OK, "jewels"), alcohol, cars, weapons, gold (?), art, uranium, and cigars. Because all those are *perfectly* ethical things to trade in. Cigars seem very American-centric, but tobacco certainly gets smuggled--- even within the U.S. (Also missing: human trafficking and counterfeit goods.)

Due to a failed bidding war I was the last person with any amount of coins, so I was able to snap up three locations on the last round and almost stage a big comeback with a large "run" (group of all different commodities.) But Kev had booked a big set a couple rounds earlier, and his lead proved unassailable after that.
Tags: games
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.